The audiences you already have
The most surprising finding in most audits is not what is missing. It is what already exists and nobody has connected.
A thriving WhatsApp channel that no one links to. A podcast with genuinely loyal listeners that the website never mentions. A broadcast slot with real reach that appears nowhere on the church's own feed. Every one of these took work to build, and every one of them is sitting in isolation, invisible to anyone who is not already in it.
This is not negligence. It is what happens when things grow in seasons. Someone started the channel during a difficult year and it worked. Someone else set up the podcast. A volunteer built a page and then moved cities. Each decision made sense at the time, and no one has ever had cause to lay them all out on one table and look at them together.
There is a related pattern worth checking for: dormant profiles from a previous season, a second account on the same platform nobody remembers creating, a page still running under someone's personal login. Each one quietly splits your reach and confuses anyone searching for you.
The work here is unglamorous and disproportionately effective. Link what exists. Retire what is dead. Put one account per platform under church ownership. Point every audience you have already earned at every other one.
The reach is usually already there. It is just not connected.